Score: 7

"Short and sweet"

submission: Nineteen Hippos

date: January 9, 2008

I enjoyed this. The only criticism I would make is the sound quality of your flash was a little bit hard to hear, thank goodness for subtitles. And lol@ "I might go back and redo it tomorrow". I wonder how long ago that was.

Score: 6

"THIS IS HALLOWEEN THIS IS HALLOWEEN"

submission: Candy Catching

date: October 14, 2006

I adore halloween, I had a complete NG profile revamp just for the holiday. You automatically would have passed in my eyes because you had a Nightmare Before Christmas song in it, which was a perfect touch. I liked how you could choose your characters because that added a little more personality. The game itself isn't a new concept but because it's halloween themed and the graphics are good and it looks as if you made this one with care and love, it's great. 'I am the clown with the tear away face, here in a flash and gone without a trace'. Ahhhh, I love halloween, Sorry! : )

Score: 4

"Nice but not NG quality"

submission: Pencils episode 2

date: October 14, 2006

It's very good for a start, your drawings are nice, and you seem to be able to animate moderately well. I don't think it's NG quality, because I would like to think that NG has the best of the best, but it's definitely not bad. You say that you haven't quite gotten the hang of flash, but you show potential. It needs to be longer and more awesome, because currently, it's really short, and while everything else is good, it needs to have some SUBSTANCE. Also, having drawings come to life isn't an original idea, and that often counts for something.

Score: 5

"Good but not catchy"

submission: HipHop001

date: August 17, 2006

It lacked a killer hook. The repeating theme wasn't very catchy, and i felt the song fading into the background. It was also much much too repetitive for hip hop. If you developed this more, it could definitely be something, but for now it sounds very much like only an underlaying of what it should be.

Score: 10

"I was filled with tears of joy"

submission: Zerok - Ninja Sounds

date: June 14, 2005

This was beautiful, it graced my first set twice and it shall many more times to come. This is the epitome of art. Consider yourselves worthy to listen to this without having to pay millions of dollars for but a glimpse of this fantastic piece of work. I commend you Zerok, you never fail to impress me.

Score: 8

"Beautiful"

submission: Te amo / I love you

date: February 13, 2005

I loved it. I love anything to do with other cultures and this was really good. The timing and all that fun stuff was right on and you were in tune and everything. As for the choice of song, I couldn't rate high because it's not your original song, but I liked the originality of the piece you chose to submit to newgrounds, I don't go to the audio portal very much, but i know alot of the stuff is techno stuff. I don't want to say anything bad about other musicians, because I know my stuff sucks, but this was really more my style and what I enjoy. It was really good.